Cash or points: is this award flight worth it?
To tell whether an award flight is worth it, subtract the award’s taxes and fees from the cash price of the same ticket, then divide by the number of points. That gives the value you get for each point, usually written in cents. If it beats what you could get for those points elsewhere, use points; if not, pay cash and keep them.
Published
The formula
Cents per point = (cash price − taxes and fees on the award) ÷ points needed × 100
Use the cash price of the same flights, in the same cabin, for the same number of people. If you’d never pay for business class, compare a business class award with the fare you would actually buy instead; that gives a more honest number.
A worked example
Say a one-way business class fare costs $1,240, and the same flight costs 60,000 points plus $86 in taxes and fees as an award.
- Cash saved by using points: $1,240 − $86 = $1,154
- Value per point: $1,154 ÷ 60,000 = $0.0192, or 1.92 cents
If you value those points at 1.5 cents each, the award is the better deal. If you value them at 2 cents or more, paying cash and keeping the points comes out ahead.
Count what the cash ticket would earn
A paid ticket usually earns airline miles and credit card points; an award ticket usually doesn’t. Subtract the value of those earnings from the cash saved.
In the example, if the paid fare would earn 3,000 miles that you value at 1.2 cents each, that’s $36. The cash saved becomes $1,154 − $36 = $1,118, and the value per point falls to 1.86 cents.
What a point is worth to you
There’s no single right value for a point. It depends on how you’d otherwise use it. Two numbers help:
- The floor. Many bank programs let you redeem points for cash or travel at a fixed rate. That rate is the least a point is worth to you, because you can always take it.
- Your usual redemption. If you regularly get more than the floor on flights you’d take anyway, that’s a fair value to compare against.
Programs also raise award prices from time to time, so points tend to lose value the longer they sit unused.
Compare like with like
- The same flights and times, or a cash fare you’d genuinely accept instead.
- The same number of people. Check that both prices cover the whole party, not one person.
- All fees in the same currency. Some awards add carrier surcharges that make the cash part much larger.
- Change and cancellation rules, which differ between paid and award tickets.
Let the assistant do the arithmetic
An assistant connected to Goliath can find the cash fare and the award price for the same route and date, then run the numbers with compare_quotes. It does exact arithmetic on the quotes: total cost, value per point with the point values you give it, and journeys that mix flights, trains and other legs. A quote with missing facts, such as unknown taxes, is left out of the ranking rather than guessed.
Ask something like: “Compare paying cash with using Aeroplan points for this flight. I value my points at 1.4 cents.” How to search award flights with an AI assistant shows how to set it up.
Questions
What is a good value per point?
It depends on what else you could do with the points. Use the cash or travel rate your bank program offers as the floor, and aim well above it for flights. Many travelers aim for about 1.5 cents or more from transferable bank points, but your own threshold matters more than a rule of thumb.
Should taxes and fees count?
Yes. Subtract the cash you still pay on the award from the cash fare before you divide, or the value per point looks better than it is.
Do award tickets earn miles?
Usually not, while a paid ticket usually does. Count the miles and card points a paid fare would earn as part of its price.
More from the blog
- How to search award flights with an AI assistant
- What is a travel MCP server?
- How current is award seat availability?
- Transfer points to airlines: what to check first
- How to search award flights for free
- What is award travel?
- AI flight search: what an assistant can do
- How to choose an award flight search tool